Indianapolis Colts All-Time Team: Best Lineup (2006–2025)
Who makes the Indianapolis Colts all-time team? We rated every player season from 2006 to 2025 (270 players) and picked the best season of each star for every spot of the lineup.
The all-time lineup
| Spot | Player | Best season | Rating | Seasons |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| QB | Peyton Manning | 2006 | 99 | 5 |
| RB | Jonathan Taylor | 2021 | 99 | 6 |
| WR | Marvin Harrison | 2006 | 99 | 3 |
| WR | Reggie Wayne | 2006 | 98 | 9 |
| TE | Dallas Clark | 2009 | 99 | 6 |
| DL | Dwight Freeney | 2009 | 98 | 7 |
| DL | DeForest Buckner | 2020 | 97 | 6 |
| LB | Zaire Franklin | 2024 | 99 | 6 |
| CB | Kenny Moore II | 2020 | 98 | 9 |
| S | Mike Adams | 2014 | 97 | 3 |
| K | Adam Vinatieri | 2013 | 94 | 12 |
Ratings (out of 99) are calculated by Football Draft Game: 17-0 from public season stats compared with the league – not official ratings.
Top 10 player seasons
- Zaire Franklin – 2024 Indianapolis Colts (99)
- Jonathan Taylor – 2021 Indianapolis Colts (99)
- Shaquille Leonard – 2018 Indianapolis Colts (99)
- Dallas Clark – 2009 Indianapolis Colts (99)
- Marvin Harrison – 2006 Indianapolis Colts (99)
- Peyton Manning – 2006 Indianapolis Colts (99)
- Jonathan Taylor – 2025 Indianapolis Colts (98)
- Zaire Franklin – 2022 Indianapolis Colts (98)
- Kenny Moore II – 2021 Indianapolis Colts (98)
- Kenny Moore II – 2020 Indianapolis Colts (98)
Best team seasons
- 2009 Indianapolis Colts: 14-2
- 2007 Indianapolis Colts: 13-3
- 2006 Indianapolis Colts: 12-4 🏆
- 2008 Indianapolis Colts: 12-4
- 2012 Indianapolis Colts: 11-5
Can you beat this team?
In Franchise mode of Football Draft Game: 17-0 you draft the Indianapolis Colts all-time team yourself, one random season at a time – then see if it goes 17-0. Play it free in your browser.
Other teams
Arizona CardinalsAtlanta FalconsBaltimore RavensBuffalo BillsCarolina PanthersChicago BearsCincinnati BengalsCleveland BrownsDallas CowboysDenver BroncosDetroit LionsGreen Bay PackersHouston TexansJacksonville JaguarsKansas City ChiefsLas Vegas RaidersLos Angeles ChargersLos Angeles RamsMiami DolphinsMinnesota VikingsNew England PatriotsNew Orleans SaintsNew York GiantsNew York JetsPhiladelphia EaglesPittsburgh SteelersSan Francisco 49ersSeattle SeahawksTampa Bay BuccaneersTennessee TitansWashington Commanders
Draft the Indianapolis Colts in Football Draft Game: 17-0 – freeFAQ
Who is the best Indianapolis Colts player since 2006?
By our ratings, Zaire Franklin in 2024 had the best season (99).
What was the best Indianapolis Colts season?
2009, with a 14-2 record.
Can I draft the Indianapolis Colts all-time team?
Yes – Franchise mode in Football Draft Game: 17-0 (free, no ads) lets you draft it and play a full season.
Draft the Indianapolis Colts in Football Draft Game: 17-0 – free